July 25, 2016

CROSS TOWN REVIEW

The Cubs and White Sox will do a short home and away four game series. The Crosstown Classic has lost its luster with all the interleague play. The rivalry has gone into a secondary phase after the White Sox won the World Series in 2005, and the Cubs had a run in 2008. More important rivalries have taken hold: Cubs-Cardinals; Sox-Royals.

At the moment the Cubs appear to be a much better club. The Cubs lead the NL Central. The Sox are sinking in the AL Central.

What fans used to do was compare starting lineups:

                                          CUBS                         WHITE SOX

Left Field                       Contreras                       Cabrera
Center Field                   Fowler                           Shuck
Right Field                     Heyward                        Eaton
Third Base                     Bryant                            Frazier
Shortstop                        Russell                          Anderson
Second Base                   Zobrist                          Lawrie
First Base                       Rizzo                             Abreu
Catcher                          Montero                         Narvarro

ROTATION                   Arrieta                            Sale
                                       Lester                             Quintana
                                       Lackey                           Shields
                                       Hammel                         Rodon
                                       Hendricks                      Gonzalez

One could argue the Sox have a better player in Cabrera in LF because Contreras is playing out of position; or that Eaton has more assists and BA than Heyward in RF; or Anderson has more potential than Russell at SS, or Navarro is a better offensive fit at catcher than Montero.

But the Cubs match up with 4 better starters than the Sox (Sale is a clear choice over current Jake).

Cubs 9 White Sox 4

And that is where the arguments start and end.
That, and the standings.

But it is the head-to-head matches that used to be the bragging rights for the summer. And usually the weaker team did better in these series.