Showing posts with label franchise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label franchise. Show all posts

November 20, 2015

GRAIN OF SALT

The Atlanta Braves is one of the best run MLB franchises. It is a subsidiary of Liberty Media, a massive communication conglomerate. It has the financial resources to be competitive year in and year out, even though the team got a suburban county to fund a brand new stadium for the team.

Braves Chairman and CEO Terry McGuirk who, gave an interview to the Atlanta Business Chronicle He had a lot to say, and for context one should read it all, but this answer, in response to a question about whether Braves’ profits are reinvested in the club or, rather, sent back up to corporate parent Liberty Media, was quite a head-turner:
Basically, all of the money at the Braves. We’ve never really lost money with the Braves. Baseball is not a widely profitable business. If you took all of the free-cash flow of all of the 30 teams, it’s pretty much zero. That’s sort of a fairly well known fact. If you actually, do have free cash flow, you’re among a minority. We have always managed the team to at least break even on free cash flow or make a little. Sometimes we’ve made more than a little. But, that puts in a minority in this business.
There are a lot of ways to measure the financial health of a baseball team and cash profit is only one of them. Indeed, it may be the least significant part of the financial picture for a team. The real game is the appreciation of franchise value, and the Braves have certainly appreciated for Liberty media. When they purchased the team in 2007 the franchise was worth $450 million. This year Forbes valued the club at $1.15 billion. And that’s despite the fact that the Braves have one of the worst local TV deals of any club. Of course, based on what McGuirk is saying, the Braves are pursuing both tracks: watching the franchise value appreciate and doing its best to break even on cash flow “or make a little.” The best of both worlds if you’re an executive in charge of a division of a large corporation.

Since baseball is a private enterprise, their "books" are not open to public inspection or audit. But realize that baseball teams have several legal accounting tricks to minimize profits (and therefore reduce taxes) as do any other major corporation. But baseball has the Veeck rule, which allows a team to both deduct the salaries of players and depreciate their contracts as a declining asset. This is a double deduction accounting method which reduces "profits" on paper.

In addition, baseball is just starting to reap the benefits of new revenue sources like the MLB Network and streaming game services.

Owners would not pay billions of dollars to lose money operating a franchise. So take any mention that baseball owners are break even propositions with a grain of salt.

January 16, 2015

OAKLAND LOSES

The San Francisco Chronicle reports that a federal appeals court on Thursday rejected efforts by the Oakland A’s and the city of San Jose to force major league baseball to let the team move to the South Bay, saying only Congress or the U.S. Supreme Court can overturn the sport’s nearly century-old exemption from antitrust laws.

The Ninth Circuit's ruling leaves the A’s and San Jose with the remaining option of asking the high court to repeal the antitrust exemption, which it established in 1922 and reaffirmed in 1953 and 1972. The exemption requires a team that wants to move outside its territory to seek the major leagues’ approval, which hasn’t been forthcoming since the A’s first floated the San Jose possibility.

“Like Casey, San Jose has struck out here,” the opinion said in the 3-0 ruling. “Only Congress and the Supreme Court are empowered to question continued vitality (of the 1972 ruling) , and with it, the fate of baseball’s singular and historic exemption from the antitrust laws.”

The appellate court described the antitrust exemption as “one of federal law’s most enduring anomalies,” acknowledging that the original 1922 ruling was based on a “soon-to-be-outmoded interpretation” of the Constitution. But he said Congress, which has the power to rewrite the antitrust law to include relocation of major league teams, has left the ruling and its successors intact.

The A's have been trying to move out of Oakland for years. The stadium is in poor condition. Oakland is the ugly sister economically to neighbor-across-the-bay, San Francisco, whose Giants own the territory rights on the east side of the bay all the way down through Silicon Valley.

Territorial rights used to be important considerations when teams joined a league. By having an exclusive presence in a town, it meant the club had a better chance of profitability. Two team towns had divided loyalties, and usually one team got the short end of the stick (politically, socially or in attendance).

But since baseball, like most major sports, has now grown past mere attendance as being the life blood of a team, the concept of territorial monopoly seems to be outdated. But teams still guard those territories so as to keep the mystic of fan serfdom. The great gnawing peeve for fans is the territorial black out rules where fans of a team just outside the club's broadcast rights territory cannot pick up their club's games.

It is still money, or the perception of losing a single dollar to a competitor, that keeps the MLB team ownership rules and restrictions in place.

December 19, 2014

BEAR (BLEEPS) IN THE WOODS

In any professional sport, management is accountable to ownership and players are accountable to coaches and coaches are accountable to management.

Such is the circle of life in pro sports.

Until you cover the Chicago Bears.

A Super Bowl expectation pre-season has turned into a Toilet Bowl of reality.

No one seems to be in charge. No seems to be listening. No one seems to know what to do to correct things. No one seems to take responsibility for their actions.

The latest madness from Halas Hall is that four hours after Coach Trestman told the media that it was not all Cutler's fault for the offensive woes, Cutler is benched for Jimmy Clausen, a player who has not taken this year a first team practice snap.

It could have been the only time that the organization decided to slap their mumbly, pouting franchise quarterback for his poor performances with some accountability, but it seems a little and too late. Management put $54 million guaranteed on the Cutler bandwagon at the beginning of the year when the team did not have to do so. Cutler has a reputation as being a "coach killer" for good reason; look at the graveyard of past offensive coordinators.

The free fall from firing a 10-6 Lovie Smith to a lackluster 8-8 season to now a potential 5-11 disaster, the Trestman era may go down as one of the worst in franchise history. A franchise that has only won 2 championships in the last 51 years.  No doubt the reason Smith was fired was because he did not get to the playoffs. But behind the scenes, Smith was welding too much power and control over personnel decisions. He was solely focused on his defense, an arrogantly outdated Tampa 2 scheme that former Bear Gary Fencik called "high school." But still, Smith's players played hard for him, and they won games.

GM Phil Emery went out of the box thinking when he hired a CFL coach in Trestman. A report surfaced recently that NFL Coach of the Year, Bruce Arians, who guided the Colts to the playoffs during a turmoil year when their head coach was battling cancer, wanted the Bears job. But when it came time to interview, Arians was told he had to go through a "fake" news conference drill, and was also told he could not hire any of his assistant coaches. Arians had dealt with the media under pressure for an entire year. It seemed like Bears management was clueless in how to interview an experienced NFL coach. But based upon the amount of control management wanted to keep, no wonder the Bears hired Trestman, a man with no NFL experience to leverage concessions on his staff.

Trestman was hired to do one thing: fix the offense. So management brought in the worst defensive coordinator from the previous season, Mel Tucker, but told him to "keep" the Lovie Smith defense so as not to offend the returning players. It should not have mattered to the players - - - professionals have to be professional and change with the times. But to hand tie Tucker was also another management intrusion and mistake.

Trestman was supposed to be a quarterback guru. He could fix Cutler's bad mechanics, bad reads, and turnover issues. The team surrounded him with All-Pro caliber wide receivers, running back and tight end. All the pieces were in place for a juggernaut offense.

But this year, the offense regressed to being middle of the pack poor. The team comes out of the gate so poorly in the first half of games that even national commentators are baffled. The team, with all the garbage points at the end of losses, still has not scored more than 28 points this season.

The head coach is responsible to get his players and the three phases of the team ready for each game. Clearly, offense, defense and special teams have been awful. Unprepared, lack of urgency, poor fundamentals and inability to play their positions are damning problems that have not been corrected week after week. Some say the players are not that talented - - - so that goes to the general manager. But he spent a ton of money on "name" free agents to shore up the lines. He made the disastrous investment in Cutler.

If anyone wants to study "How not to Run a Sports Franchise," one only has to review the Bears' 2014 season.