August 13, 2013

HOME GROWN TALENT

Deadspin linked to an interesting article written by Domenic Lanza. He decided to sort through the major league rosters to find each team's Home Grown Talent. It is an exercise to show how well each team's drafting and minor league development has been at the major league level. It would also show what teams would look like if MLB had a "no trade rule," i.e. you had to develop your own talent.

He penned the following Cubs roster:


Chicago Cubs
Starting Pitchers
Andrew Cashner 

 Jon Garland
Kyle Lohse
Ricky Nolasco
Jeff Samardzija 

 Bullpen
Al Alburquerque 

 Jerry Blevins
Scott Downs
Rich Hill
Carlos Marmol
Sean Marshall
James Russell  

Catchers
Jose Molina
Geovany Soto

 Infielders
Darwin Barney
Starlin Castro
Ronny Cedeno
Josh Donaldson 

 Ryan Flaherty
Josh Vitters  

Outfielders
Tony Campana
Tyler Colvin
Sam Fuld
Brett Jackson
Junior Lake 


Lanza opined that this is a bad team. There’s some young talent in Cashner Castro, and Lake but such a club would be near last place in any league. As a result, he can see why Epstein had to blow up the minors to rebuild.

What is interesting is that only five Cubs on their current roster are farm hands, and one (Lake) is playing out of position. Also, most of the Cub talent are utility-bench players and not full time starters.