He was drafted in 1992 by the Yankees.
This draft shows what the promise and expectation is for prospects, but history reveals reality. From wikipedia:
Only seven players of the 38 first round selections made an All-Star team. That is only an 18 percent impact player ratio. And of these selections, only Jeter stands out which shows that there is really only a 2.5 percent chance that first rounder could be a Hall of Fame talent.